For Whom Did Christ Die? -- By: Lewis Sperry Chafer
BSac 137:548 (Oct 80) p. 310
For Whom Did Christ Die?
[Lewis Sperry Chafer, The Late Founder, First President, and Professor of Systematic Theology, Editor, Bibliotheca Sacra 1940-52, Dallas Theological Seminary]
[Editor’s Note: This article first appeared in Bibliotheca Sacra in January 1948. It is reprinted now, with minor editorial changes, because of continuing discussions on this theological issue.]
For many centuries the question, “For whom did Christ die?” has divided and still divides some of the most orthodox and scholarly theologians. On the one hand those who according to theological usage are known as “limited redemptionists” contend that Christ died only for that elect company who were predetermined of God to be saved; and on the other hand those who are known as “unlimited redemptionists” contend that Christ died for all men. The issue is well defined, and men of sincere loyalty to the Word of God and who possess true scholarship are found on both sides of the controversy.
It is true that the doctrine of a limited redemption is one of the five points of Calvinism, but not all who are rightfully classified as Calvinists accept this one feature of that system. It is equally true that all Arminians are unlimited redemptionists, but to hold the doctrine of unlimited redemption does not necessarily make one an Arminian. There is nothing incongruous in the fact that many unlimited redemptionists believe, in harmony with all Calvinists, in the unalterable and eternal decree of God whereby all things were determined after His own will, and in the sovereign election of some to be saved (but not all), and in the divine predestination of those who are saved to the heavenly glory prepared for them. Without the slightest inconsistency the unlimited redemptionists may believe in an election according to sovereign grace, that none but the elect will be saved, that all of the elect will be saved, and that the elect are by divine enablement alone called out of the state of spiritual death from which they are impotent to
BSac 137:548 (Oct 80) p. 311
take even one step in the direction of their own salvation. The text, “No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him” (John 6:44), is as much a part of the one system of doctrine as it is of the other.
It is not easy to disagree with good and great men. However, as they appear on each side of this question, it is impossible to entertain a conviction and not oppose those who are of a contrary mind. The disagreement now under discussion is not between orthodox and heterodox men; it is within the fellowship of those who have most in common and...
Click here to subscribe